Disclosure: Social Crave may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Learn more.
beehiiv and Substack are the two names most new newsletter writers end up comparing. Both let you publish to email and the web, grow a list and charge readers for a subscription. But they make money in opposite ways. Substack is free to use and takes a cut when you earn. beehiiv charges a monthly fee on its paid plans and takes nothing from your subscription revenue.
This beehiiv vs Substack comparison looks at fees, free plans, discovery, ownership and day-to-day use, so you can decide where to start. Figures come from beehiiv’s pricing page and Substack’s help centre article How much does Substack cost?, both checked on 29 October 2026. We haven’t run our own deliverability tests, so we don’t make claims about inbox placement.
beehiiv vs Substack: Quick Verdict
- Pick Substack if: you’re a writer starting from zero, you want to publish for free with no subscriber cap, and you’d like Substack’s app, Notes and recommendations to help readers find you.
- Pick beehiiv if: you see your newsletter as a business, you want to keep 100% of subscription revenue, or you plan to earn from ads, sponsorships and digital products as well as paid subscriptions.
- Fees in short: Substack keeps 10% of each subscription payment, plus Stripe fees. beehiiv takes 0% of paid subscriptions (Stripe fees still apply), but you need a paid plan to charge readers. Lite starts at $49 a month billed yearly for up to 1,000 subscribers.
- Our pick: Substack for hobby writers and first-timers who want discovery; beehiiv once paid revenue passes roughly $500 a month, or from day one if you want ads and full control over your brand.
Fees and Pricing Compared (October 2026)
The two platforms price in completely different ways, so a direct plan-for-plan table is tricky. Here’s what each one charges a creator.
| Plan / fee | Price | Subscribers | Paid subscriptions? | Cut of subscription revenue |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Substack | $0 to publish | Unlimited | Yes (minimum $5/mo or $30/yr) | 10% + Stripe fees |
| Substack custom domain | One-time $50 (optional) | n/a | n/a | n/a |
| beehiiv Free | $0 | Up to 2,500 | No | n/a |
| beehiiv Lite | $49/mo billed yearly ($588 a year) or $59 monthly | Priced at up to 1,000 (sold up to 100,000) | Yes (1 paid tier) | 0% + Stripe fees |
| beehiiv Pro | $95/mo billed yearly ($1,140 a year) or $109 monthly | Priced at up to 1,000 (sold up to 250,000) | Yes (unlimited tiers) | 0% + Stripe fees |
| beehiiv Enterprise | Custom | Custom | Yes | 0% + Stripe fees |
Sources: beehiiv.com/pricing and Substack’s “How much does Substack cost?” help article (updated 29 Sept 2026), both checked 29 Oct 2026. Prices in USD. beehiiv’s Lite price rises with list size, for example $69/mo billed yearly at up to 2,500 subscribers and $119/mo at up to 10,000. Pro is $129/mo yearly at 2,500 and $199/mo at 10,000. Substack’s minimum price applies to US-dollar Stripe accounts; other currencies may vary.
Substack’s fees in detail
Publishing on Substack is free no matter how many subscribers you have. Once you turn on paid subscriptions, Substack keeps 10% of each subscription payment. On top of that, Stripe charges card processing (Substack lists 2.9% + $0.30 per payment for US cards) and a 0.7% Stripe Billing fee on recurring payments. Local payment methods have their own Stripe fees, which depend on the country of your Stripe account, so UK writers should check Stripe’s UK pricing. Subscriptions bought through Substack’s iOS app can cost readers more to cover Apple’s fees, but Substack’s 10% is still based on your web price.
beehiiv’s fees in detail
beehiiv says it takes 0% of your paid subscription revenue and that you keep everything minus Stripe’s standard processing fee (it quotes 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction). The catch is that paid subscriptions, the Ad Network, paid recommendations and email automations all need Lite or higher. The Free plan is for building a list of up to 2,500 subscribers, not for charging readers. All beehiiv plans, including Free, have unlimited email sends.
Where the break-even point sits
A simple way to compare: Substack’s 10% costs more than beehiiv’s fee once your paid revenue is bigger than ten times beehiiv’s monthly price. With beehiiv Lite at $49 a month (billed yearly, up to 1,000 subscribers), that’s about $490 a month in subscription revenue. With a list of up to 2,500 subscribers, Lite is $69 a month yearly, so the break-even rises to about $690 a month.
Worked example: a newsletter with 2,000 free readers and 100 paid subscribers at $8 a month brings in $800 a month. Substack’s cut would be $80 a month ($960 a year). beehiiv Lite at that list size is $69 a month billed yearly ($828 a year), with no revenue share. Stripe fees apply on both. The saving is small at this level, but it grows with every new paid subscriber, because beehiiv’s fee is tied to list size, not revenue.
Features Compared
1. Discovery and growth
This is Substack’s biggest strength. Its network includes cross-publication recommendations, Notes (a social feed), category leaderboards, an Explore page and search across all Substack publications. The Substack app shows readers a home feed of notes, posts and recommendations, so a new writer can pick up subscribers from inside the network, not only from their own promotion. Substack also has a reader referral programme with milestone rewards.
beehiiv has a Recommendation Network on every plan, including Free, plus a referral programme from Lite (3 reward milestones on Lite, unlimited on Pro). Paid recommendations, where you earn for promoting other newsletters, need Lite. beehiiv doesn’t have a reader app or social feed like Substack’s, so growth relies more on your website, social media, SEO and recommendations from other newsletters.
2. Ways to earn
Substack is built around paid subscriptions: monthly, yearly and founding member plans, free trials, coupons, gift and group subscriptions. beehiiv covers paid subscriptions too (from Lite), and adds an Ad Network, programmatic ads, a sponsorship storefront (Pro), digital products, tip jars and paid recommendations. If you want to earn from free readers through ads and sponsors, beehiiv gives you more built-in options. Note that beehiiv says the Ad Network and recommendations aren’t available during the trial or in all regions.
3. Branding and ownership
Both let you export your subscriber list, so you’re never locked in. Substack’s export includes your posts, subscriber list and stats. Your Substack still sits inside Substack’s design and network, and a custom domain is a one-time $50. beehiiv gives you a website builder, custom pages and templates, and Pro lets you remove beehiiv branding from your newsletter and website. If you want the newsletter to look like your own brand, beehiiv gives you more control.
4. Automations and segmentation
beehiiv Lite includes up to 10 live custom automations (welcome series, tag-based flows, paid subscription triggers), and Pro makes them unlimited with click-triggered automations and A/B splits. It also has segments, surveys, polls and A/B testing of emails from Lite. Substack keeps things simple: you write a post and send it to free or paid readers. For writers who just want to publish, that’s a plus. For anyone running funnels or selling products, it’s a limit.
5. Writing, podcasts and video
Substack has a clean editor, Notes, chat, podcasts and live video in its app. beehiiv offers a newsletter editor, website and podcast hosting on every plan (5,000 monthly downloads on Free), audio newsletters on Pro and an in-editor AI tool on paid plans. If you use AI to draft issues, our guide to writing blog posts with AI has a workflow that works for newsletters too. If you record a podcast, our guide to editing a podcast in Descript covers the editing side.
6. Analytics and support
beehiiv’s analytics lookback is 30 days on Free, 12 months on Lite and unlimited on Pro, with standard human support on Lite and priority support on Pro (Free gets the beehiiv Agent assistant). Substack gives you subscriber and growth stats, including where readers came from and how many arrived through the network.
beehiiv vs Substack: Pros and Cons
Substack pros
- Free to publish with no subscriber cap.
- Built-in discovery: app, Notes, recommendations, leaderboards and search.
- Very simple to set up and write.
- You only pay when you earn.
Substack cons
- 10% of every subscription payment, on top of Stripe fees.
- Limited design and branding control.
- No email automations or built-in ad network.
- Your growth is tied to Substack’s network and app.
beehiiv pros
- 0% take rate on paid subscriptions.
- Free plan up to 2,500 subscribers with unlimited sends.
- Ad Network, sponsorships, digital products and paid recommendations.
- Automations, segments, A/B tests and a website builder.
beehiiv cons
- Paid subscriptions need Lite ($49/mo yearly or $59 monthly at 1,000 subscribers).
- No reader app or social feed for discovery.
- Removing beehiiv branding needs Pro.
- Prices are in US dollars, so UK creators should allow for exchange rates and card fees.
Which Should You Start On?
- First-time writers and essayists: Substack. It costs nothing, and the network can bring early readers while you find your voice.
- Writers planning paid subscriptions at scale: beehiiv. Once you pass roughly $500 a month in paid revenue, the 0% take rate saves money every month.
- Newsletters funded by ads and sponsors: beehiiv, for its Ad Network and sponsorship storefront.
- Creators selling courses, ebooks or templates: beehiiv, or Kit. Our Kit vs beehiiv comparison and Kit review cover that route.
Moving from Substack to beehiiv
- Export your data from Substack’s Settings page (Exports). You get your posts, subscriber list and stats as a zip file.
- Start on beehiiv Free if your list is under 2,500 and you don’t charge yet, or try Lite if you have paid subscribers.
- Import your subscribers and rebuild your welcome email first.
- Plan the paid move carefully. Paid subscribers are billed through Stripe, so check beehiiv’s help docs on moving paid subscriptions before you switch.
- Tell your readers about the move so they recognise your new sender details.
Want the full picture on beehiiv’s plans? Our beehiiv review covers each tier, and our guide on how to start a newsletter walks you through your first issue.
Substack Alternatives Worth a Look
beehiiv isn’t the only Substack alternative. Our guide to the best newsletter platforms for creators compares beehiiv, Substack, Kit and Ghost. If your newsletter is really a marketing tool for a business, our Kit vs Mailchimp comparison may be more useful.
Our Verdict: beehiiv or Substack?
Start on Substack if you want to write and be found; start on beehiiv if you want to build a newsletter business. Substack’s free publishing and network discovery make it the easiest place to begin, and you pay nothing until readers pay you. The trade-off is 10% of your subscription revenue forever. beehiiv’s 0% take rate, ad tools and automations make it the better long-term home once you earn more than about $500 a month, or from day one if ads, sponsors and your own brand matter more than an in-app audience. Whichever you choose, a grammar checker helps every issue read cleanly; see Grammarly vs QuillBot.
Try beehiiv free → Start on Substack →
Frequently Asked Questions
Is beehiiv better than Substack?
It depends on your goal. beehiiv is better for newsletter businesses that want to keep all subscription revenue and earn from ads, sponsors and products. Substack is better for writers who want to publish for free and get discovered through its app and recommendations.
How much does Substack take from paid subscriptions?
Substack keeps 10% of each subscription payment. Stripe also charges card processing (2.9% + $0.30 per payment for US cards) and a 0.7% Billing fee on recurring payments. Publishing free posts costs nothing.
Does beehiiv take a cut of paid subscriptions?
No. beehiiv says it takes 0% of paid subscription revenue, so you only pay Stripe’s processing fee. You do need a paid plan, starting with Lite at $49 a month billed yearly for up to 1,000 subscribers, to offer paid subscriptions.
Is beehiiv free?
Yes. beehiiv Free costs nothing for up to 2,500 subscribers, with unlimited email sends, a website, a podcast and the Recommendation Network. Paid subscriptions, ads and automations need Lite or Pro.
When is it cheaper to switch from Substack to beehiiv?
Roughly when your monthly subscription revenue is more than ten times beehiiv’s monthly fee. With Lite at $49 a month (billed yearly, up to 1,000 subscribers), that’s about $490 a month in paid revenue; at up to 2,500 subscribers it’s about $690.
Can I move my newsletter from Substack to beehiiv?
Yes. Substack lets you export your posts, subscriber list and stats from Settings, and you can import them into beehiiv. Check beehiiv’s help docs before moving paid subscribers, since they’re billed through Stripe.
Sources: beehiiv pricing, plan comparison and FAQ, Substack: How much does Substack cost?, Substack: setting up a paid publication and Substack features, checked 29 October 2026. Prices in USD and may change.
